episode iii, the backstroke of the west
i saw revenge of the sith last weekend at a local theater with my friend joe who was in town on business. it was much better than the first two movies and a fitting end (err.. middle) to the star wars saga.
the next day i was walking past my friendly dvd salesperson and decided to check out revenge of the sith. i was assured the quality was good and for 7rmb why not give it a shot.
aside from the counters on the top of the screen and a distorted perspective it was ok- not high quality but watchable. the captions were a hilarious surprise- a direct english translation of the chinese interpretation of what the script was saying. it varied from being somewhat close to the script to being 'far far away'....

amazingly enough, the beginning scroll is mistranslated even though the words are right there on the screen.

star war (just one)

'the backstroke of the west' is the english translation of the chinese title.

anakin: "this is where the fun begins"

obi wan: "let them pass between us"

anonymous doomed fighter pilot: "they're all over me"

obi wan, space battle strategist.

obi wan grows impatient with r2.

the chancellor warns anakin and obi wan that count dooku is... big.

obi wan assures the chancellor that it's no problem.

count dooku talks tough.

that's chancellor palpatine speaking, talking about obi wan.

general grevious gets some bad news.

the general considers punishing his troops.

anakin taunts general grevious.

the general fires off a snappy comeback

ummm... ????

we gonna rock down to... lemon avenue.

padme the homemaker

anakin tells padme about his dream.

on the hoof - idiom, 'not yet butchered; alive. used especially of cattle'

hallelujah!

yoda: "premonitions? premonitions?"

sounds like something yoda might actually say... maybe.

anakin is haunted by dreamses.

troopseses!

anakin gets frustrated with the jedi council.

the chancellor tells anakin the story of darth plagueis the wise, aka the dintmeister.

plagueis learned how to become... strong and big.

but he lost his power and died...

...then was killed by his land, so he could sleep. a tragic story indeed.

this seemed completely random until i figured out that 'jedi council' was being translated into chinese then back to english as 'the presbyterian church'.

anakin: "obi wan, may the force be with you"

tion medon: "on the tenth level, thousands of battledroids"

obi wan: "hello there"

the general tells his troops to back off, he'll take care of obi wan.

...but is it big?

the chancellor delivers anakin some bad news.

mace windu reads the chancellor his rights.

anakin bargains for the life of his cuckoldry. cuckoldry?

anakin gets a new name.

the emporer: "rise!"

the emporer tells anakin... umm... something.

anakin: "i agree."

the emperor: "do what must be done, lord vader."

yoda: "goodbye chewbacca."

c3po tells the amorous couple to get a room.

padme: "no thank you, c3po."

obi wan: "who could have done this?"

obi wan can't face what he must do.

yoda insists...

...and explains that the person he once knew noed longer is.

how about a snickers?

anakin tells padme about his new virtues, now being both strong and big.

padme doesn't want strong and big- she also doesn't want to walk on a road meant for running about.

lier!!!

obi wan has heard enough.

meanwhile, the emperor reveals his true ambitions.

anakin taunts, but...

...obi wan stands on higher ground...

...and proclaims his love.

this translation is classic. darth vader is actually shouting, "nooooooooooooo..."
captions there be, mangled they are.
* * *
due to popular request i've (finally) figured out how to use subrip to pull the complete english subtitle file off the dvd. here they are in all their glory.
check out these mangled rocky balboa captions.
i've transcribed some of the dialogue here. dan in hangzhou bought the same dvd as i did- he has put up some different screen shots on his blog- check them out. backstroke anime art. this post has been boing boing'd, ytmnd'd, farked, and tucker max'd.





633 Comments:
Damn I knew I should have bought this when there. It's worth it just for the subtitles! Be worth making up a 6-DVD set for $4. I wonder if all the subtitles are still bad, since actual originals were released - have you noticed if the good quality transfer ones (i.e. DVD copies rather than screeners/screenings) actually use the real subitltes or do they also do the dual translation?
Wow. I am sending this to our Star Wars mailing list at the office.
amit- i haven't actually bought some good quality transfer dvds yet so i'm not sure. there ought to be some good copies out there if they're taken from a master copy.
initial- lemme know their feedback. =)
GENIUS! I laughed my ass off.
jeremy,
I thought you might like to know that I linked to this entry. Great work! Keep it up.
http://www.sinosplice.com/weblog/archives/2005/06/14/backstroke-of-the-west
LOL, thats too funny.
BRILLIANT!
I'm passing this around the office!
Wonderful!
boing boing'ed you've been
Having been "made by the Presbyterian Church" myself, I wonder what amazing powers I haven't been exercising?
You've been boing-boinged ... that's pretty cool!
MORE! Please... more... Even if transcribed and in plaintext, I must have more!
Hilarious! Thanks so much for sharing..came here via boingboing!
I will buy this off you. This freaking great!
This version of SW must be included on ALL future collectors edition of Star Wars.
God, oh my, hilarious frickin tranlation of enjoyable french fries.
www.cravingmusic.com
i picked up a bootleg of Minority Report in NYC Chinatown a couple years ago which also had awful subtitles, including an instance in the first five minutes in which an exclaimation that sounded pretty much like "Shit!" was subtitled as "Shift!" If you're not gonna learn how to curse, you shouldn't bother with foriegn languages at all
Hilarious...I'm going to cop a copy today...thanks for putting a smile on my face!!!
Toast me! I say you got to toast me!
Oy vey!
Thank you for posting these. I'll just go lie down for a bit.
Oyoyoy....
This post has been removed by a blog administrator.
sheer brilliance!
this is the stuff all your base videos are made of!
See, this is why I hate anti-piracy measures-- I'm never gonna be able to find a copy of this in LA. I would pay twice as much for this than the inevitable Sith DVD is gonna cost. They don't sell pirated material on eBay, do they?
It's an improvement on Lucas' script if you ask me.
Good stuff, let's see some more!
Haha, I just got back from Xi'an, and picked up three different copies of the Sith, in search for that "perfect copy" out there that I never found. I never bothered to check the subtitles on that one, since i figured most would be terrrible, like the "danny the dog" dvd (aka unleashed) had subtitles from some Dolph Lundgren movie. I was like, "wow, I've never seen Morgan Freeman swear so much in one sentence!!!"
It's an improvement on Lucas' script if you ask me.
We are in agreement, anonymous brother.
I'd say something's been gained (rather than lost)in the translation. Riotous! I'll be going to China within the next year - please the fates that I can find a copy.
Please transcribe this. It would do nothing but make me happy.
where can i find this dvd???
hi all! thanks for the comments.
initael- i guess it spread pretty far outside your office distribution list!
alex cline- i'll transcribe a couple of scenes. takes a while to do so i'll limit it to some of the cheesier dialogue.
time bandit- i found this copy in the xiang yang market. my sister tried to buy another copy but it was a different (better) transfer with subtitles from another movie.
absolutely priceless.
Wow! Worth it just for the subtitles :)
Is there any way the pictures can be posted elsewhere? quite a few of the images are broken.
This is absolutely great. I laughed my ass off. They should sell it as an offical alternative release.
This is 10 kinds of awesome.
win
LOLOL!!!!!!!!!!!
XDDDDDDDDDDDDD!!!!!!!!!!!!
*passes out from laughing so much!(for real)*
i want to buy it
i want to buy it
This site is too awesome o.o
I'd love to have a copy of thay video.
If you have a spare one, please send it over here to Manila, will pay for your expenses :D
--adrian
? ????? ? ??????!
??????????? ????.
Hilarious. I want a copy of this awesome version!
This is... this is genius. Please rip it, then put it up as a torrent. I'll seed this copy... forever! LOL.
?????????? ) ? ????? ???? ))))))))) ?? ??? ????? ??????? )
I am soo going to check around sidestalls for these subs.
:D
You should really make a DVD-rip and put up a .torrent of it somewhere. :-)
Comedy gold! That last screen really wraps it up :D
For the love of...!
Please rip this, or at least the subtitles! This is gold. :D
Awesome!
The Backstroke of the West, I'm still laughing.....
I want, I want, please post a torrent somewhere. But, as has been noted earlier, George Lucas should have hired this guy as his script-writer.
keep refreshing and the pics will get back. damn. this is a funny.
Incomparable.
etc., etc.
This post has been removed by a blog administrator.
Ya know I think they mistook Yoda for Golem there... "Dreamses"
Hilarious find. I'm in agreement that you should torrent this somewhere.
I've got to find out why the Chinese think we're having sex when we're frustrated. Anyone get that?
Brilliant.
great stuff man , well done an thank you...
wtf?! guess the chinese are better off pirating videos than actually editing them.
My sides hurt from laughing so hard! I love it! How can I get my hands on a copy of this?
omg!! this is GREAT!! my best friend is currently in beijing and was disappointed to find SW would be released later in china than in the US. im not sure if shes seen it yet, but i sent her a link to your page. i know shes gonna get a kick out of this!!
that's awesome! I'd love a good DVD copy w/the double translations. Now if someone redubbed the audio to match those captions that'd be priceless!
Please, please fix the broken image links. I need to know the parts I am missing.
There are some good DVD rips out there if you have a newsgroup membership you should be able to find one no problem.
This is hilarious btw..
The Backstroke of the West and other translation... this is one of the best jokes :D
Thanks for posting it
You know, I couldn't care for Star Wars until now. You're awesome
- Laura M
total classic, please tell me you have more dodgy translations...
Tricksy troopseses, they wants the Precious!
re Darth Vader's wants.
There is no word in chinese that translates to "No"... you need a verb, like want.
HAHAHAHAHAHAHA! Omigosh! These are soooo funny! I was trying so hard not to laugh out loud because I'm at work. It didn't work too well...
I am a "Jedi" like my father before me... Now why the heck didn't my father teach me cool stuff like telekinesis or Telepathy and how to see visions of my other family members at a distance or make them hear me without using a phone....HAH!
Good site :D
Great find! thanks for sharing it. This ended up posted on a forum I'm an admin on. A few of the pics were down, but the 70% that weren't were more than worth the visit. Who know the Presbyterian Church are the last bastion of the Jedi?
OH MY GOD. Yeah, I'll seed the torrent, too, for the rest of my life, this is so hilarious. I got this URL from a friend of mine, and am sending it to all the StarWars fans I know. DEFNINATELY a must-see. PLEASE torrent! Please please please!
shoshigana@yahoo.com
I laughed so hard I nearly sprayed coffee all over my screen.
Flash Walker has an iron jaw and a granite cock.
Hi. I cannot be bothered to scroll up and read all comments, but I think I managed to work out why the sub is as it is (for example, why the word 'elephant' appears at all...) in between bursts of laughter...Basically it is the English translated to proper Chinese, but a catastrophically bad and character by character translationi from that Chinese sub to this 'English' sub...
Good one though, I have to admit...but shameful. If they are going to pirate something, at least they should do it nicely...
Wow, an iron jaw AND a granite cock.
He has the makings of a champ...
coooooooooooockable.
Do not want!! troopsses no take precious!!
Do not want!!
hahahahhahahahahahahahahaha
im saving this page to HD and burning it on a cd and making 2 copies
hahahahahahahaha
lol great one. Like everyone said please rib this or something.
Yeah.. some pics are broken =(
It was funny though, I saw the whole thing before the bandwith was exceeded on a few of the images.
Am I the only one troubled by the fact that China refers to the Sith as the West and the Jedi Order as the Presbyterian Church?
need to alter some links you seem to have outsiders hotlinking your images elsewhere.
holy frickin crap!
I agree - this NEEDS to be torrented. I'll also offer to seed it, this is a treasure that deserves to be spread amongst the masses.
Absolute genius.
Wow, my Chinese fellows must have been on crack translating this. Or . . . they have a great sense of humor.
Well, I wish I could have this copy of RotS. I really do.
Face explode boom with big laughy of smilewide.
Dreamses and troopseses? Smeagol hates the hobitses!
+1 for torrent
Fan-fucking-tastic.
.....Nyargs.
Hell, I'll BUY a copy from you...please...moxy@tmbg.org
Well, the apparently random profanity might have something to do with the similarity between the Chinese for "do" and "fuck" - "R2, what are you doing?" could become "R2, what are you fucking?" or something of that nature.
Love that the Jedi council Chinese is translated back as Presbyterian Church. It makes some sense, actally -- the ideas of democracy (a real democracy) in which members elect their leaders from amongest themselves.
Huh. Anyway, I'll give that more thought than it deserves. I was raised Presbyterian, but no longer consider myself one. But finally something I can bring up at dinner that's unlikely to offend any of us. Hoo.
Awesome, by the way. Thanks for sharing.
I think I've seen one version of the original Chinese translations somewhere around, and really, the translations are perfectly fine. It's only when people try to literally translate the Chinese back into English that chaos ensue. It's hilarious, though.
wahahaha! this rocks so hard!
we saw something similar to this but the movie was Ben Stiller's dodgeball but this one beats it hands down!
I need a copy of this like like a junkie needs a fix. Please, somebody hook us up.
quote: If you're not gonna learn how to curse, you shouldn't bother with foriegn languages at all.
Heh...
You should totally rip this and have someone seed it on piratebay.org or torrentreactor.net so we can all enjoy it. :D
This is cool! hahaha In the Philippines though a DVD of any movie some aren't shown yet is worth 80 pesos about USD 1.20
Oh my god. I'm linking this on my website immediately.
presbyterian church is not the translation of jedi council but the translation of temple
Bad this is! I'm in pain now. Major pain. But it was fun.
I love "troopseses" - it implies some sort of multiple plural that is philosophically very interesting!
- Katta
Ok, im just laughing out loud here.