close
The Wayback Machine - https://web.archive.org/web/20100106153942/http://www.labourlist.org:80/



Loading... Please wait...

LiveLIST

<<  Wednesday, January 6th >>

08:40 How airbrushed was Dave? - Next Left

08:40 The Conservatives' £34bn credibility gap - Labour Party

<<  Tuesday, January 5th >>

21:45 Anjem Choudary got what he wanted: five minutes on Radio 5 - The Samosa

13:00 Tory NHS policy is confused and contradictory - Coffee House

12:50 John Prescott: BBC Director says Taxpayers' Alliance is "not impartial" - Go Fourth

12:50 London comedian Alan Davies calls Boris Johnson a "fraud" over fare rises - New Statesman

12:20 VideoList Government boiler scrappage scheme launched to praise - LabourList

12:15 Rachel Sylvester: Labour strategy still not agreed between Mandelson and Balls - Times

10:30 Clegg: Lib Dems are not or sale - Times

10:30 Cameron's "lone-star" strategy gives Gordon Brown hope - Telegraph

<<  Monday, January 4th >>

18:45 What can we learn from January 2005 opinion polls? - Political Betting

21:45 Gordon Brown: Wootton Bassett march "offensive" - Mirror

18:45 Is Cameron cowing in the face of pressure? - Coffee House

18:40 Election 2010: the online battleground -Channel 4 News

15:10 VideoList Balls: We will guarantee 1-to1 learning so no child falls behind - LabourList

13:30 Dishonest Tories are playing fantasy politics - Liberal Democrats

13:00 Tories' Dave-specific campaign looks too Presidential - Political Betting

13:00 Lib Dems condemned for "sexually gratutitous" attacks on opponents - Conservative Home

12:30 James Crabtree: The left can't afford to wait for the big idea - Fabian Review

12:30 Harriet Harman: Fare rises show just how out of touch Boris Johnson is - Evening Standard

12:30 The two faces of David Cameron on the NHS - Labour Matters

1o:45  VideoList Darling: Tory budgeting has a £34bn black hole - LabourList

09:30 Happy 5th birthday, Freedom of Information - Guardian

09:30 Darling finds a £50bn hole in Tory budget plans - but the Tories cry foul - Times

09:30 Miliband "readies war chest for leadership battle" - Telegraph

09:30 Jackie Ashley: Labour and the Tories both need the same thing: the Lib Dems - Guardian

09:20 2009 was the year the left came of age in the blogosphere - Iain Dale

08:20 VideoList The election campain has arrived - and could soon bore us silly - LabourList

00:00 VideoList School pupils will receive personal finance lessons - LabourList

00:00 Fraser Nelson on Cameron: If you have nothing to say, say nothing - News of the World

Image

Image

Image

Cameron's Councils

Labour reaction to Hoon-Hewitt letter

By Alex Smith / @alexsmith1982

UPDATING...

Some reaction to the letter from Twitter and elsewhere...

Ed Balls
We're getting on with the job of government. Most people are looing at this and thinking we've lost our marbles; the important thing is that we get on, have a strengthening recovery. The majority of the PLP will have seen Gordon Brown doing brilliantly at PMQs, really putting David Cameron on the spot. I've got a lot of respect for Geoff and Patricia, but I don't they're speaking for the majority of the PLP. I've spoken to the PM, but he's getting on with doing the job; he's got a busy job this afternoon. There's always been noising off - in any political party. Gordon Brown is the best leader to take us into the election and the best person to take Britain through the recession. Today will be seen as a damp squib, the reality is that we are united. It's frustrating to have had a really good PMQs and then have the media moving on to these issues. Peter Manelson and Shaun Woodward are both behind the PM - and we'll see that from other cabinet ministers in the coming hours. The real politics and divisions could be seen in PMQs. This Labour Party is more united now than it's ever been. We have to take the argument to the country in a disciplined way. This afternoon is a diversion, but we'll move beyond it very quickly. Peter Mandelson put it very well: the cabinet is united behind Gordon Brown. We can win the argument at the ballot box. This week has been a very good week for the Labour goverment.

Peter Mandelson
No one should over react to this initiative. The Prime Minister continues to have the support of the cabinet. We will carry on as normal.

Will Straw says "Hewitt and Hoon are Labour's Dumb and Dumber"

Hoon Blewitt

Shaun Woodward
This is a school yard campaign. I'm 100% behind Gordon Brown because he's done a superb job. Around Britain, people will be astonished by this action. We think the right thing to o is get on and sort out the country. Jack Straw and Alistair Darling are doing their jobs. Geoff and Pat should withdraw this.

@alexsmith1982
One of the "usual suspects" is privately saying this "plot" is a "damp squib" <---It's going nowhere

@alexsmith1982
I think it's probably time for a secret ballot we can all take part in.

John Mann
Pat Hewitt's been raking it in from the private sector using her contacts book. This is going nowhere; it'll be over by the end of the day. Hoon has sour grapes because he didn't get the gravy train European job -- I'd like to take him into a backroom and sort him out personally. They're two pompous idiots.

Charles Clarke
I have written to Tony Lloyd, the Chairman of the Parliamentary Labour Party, to support Geoff Hoon's and Patricia Hewitt's proposal for a secret ballot of the Parliamentary Labour Party. I believe that this is the best way to resolve the many concerns which exist within the PLP and the ballot could be organized in a very few days. If such a ballot does confirm the Prime Minister in his leadership I will categorically accept that result and give him my public and private support through to the General Election.

Margaret Beckett
This is a waste of time, a big mistake - it should be ignored.

Patricia Hewitt
Supporters of the PM should welcome and support the secret ballot. It's clear in retrospect that it's a pity that there was no leadership election when Tony Blair left in 2007. A ballot could happen next Monday. Geoff and I have not been canvassing on this; this is not a plot. We've one this because we believe this is in the best interests of the Labour Party. We want an end to the public division, the briefings. The division is weakening our attack on the Conservatives. We've ha months punctutaed by public calls for the PM to go, by resignation, by speculation, by private worry. I have people in my constituency who strongly support the PM, but who want the matter resolved. We're saying quite straightforwardly and publicly: secret ballot, do it quickly, so everyone can abide by the result.

Number 10
Labour doesn't want a vote on the leadership.; it is ludicrous to suggest it would be helpful.

David Blunkett
A secret ballot is not possible maccording to Labour Party rules.

Tony Lloyd
Gordon Brown will be the leader next week and at the general election. There won't be a secret ballot because there is not the demand. It's pinprick stuff, but it deflects from us talking about our own policies.

Geoff Hoon
As a former chief whip I've been extremely concerned by the level of doubt in the PLP. I've had several emails within minutes saying what a good idea this is...If there is a clear majority of the PLP in favour of maintaining the current leaership, we can go on and fight the election...There are large concerns amongst Labour MPs...a widesprea group of MPs...about our inability to get our message across, and continuing questions about the Labour leadership...It will not be in the interest of the Labour Party to go into an election campaign with these issues rumbling on. If this matter is resolved once an for all, then everyone has to accept the result. Clarifying matters will help. The choice is between continuing ivision an uncertaintly an resolving the matter and uniting behind a leader.

Tony Lloyd, Chair PLP
"This is a diversion, not where we ought to be heading...there is no constitutional provision for this kind of sideshow"

@jessica_asato
I am at a loss for words. The time for complaining was June. Not now.

@AndrewLomas
This is just self-indulgence from people who could have spoken up at any time in the past 2 years. Why now?!

@CharlieWhelan
Would like to tweet what all the Labour Party members are saying about hoon and hewitt but mostly too abusive.

@MartinBright
Rather brilliant wheeze from Hoon and Hewitt. Is Gordon enough of a democrat? I wonder

@MartinBright
It's now or never

@Jessica_Asato
My money is on never

Luke Akehurst
Bizarre, weirdly timed and destructive.

Geraldine Smith MP
A secret ballot is a coward's charter..this is a small group of people...they've been pulling these stunts for a year...I'm extremely disappointed

@anthonypainter
Even if there were to be a ballot, it would only have one outcome. So what's the point in this? Futile and damaging.

@shamikdas
the idea of a secret ballot, a secret f***ing ballot of 352 people to decide the fate of the PM?! This is Britain!

@TomBage
Miliband, Mandelson, Darling or Straw. If you have the bloodlust, now's your chance.

@conn1231
Is Hoon and Hewitt actually really are labour people shouldn't they be fighting for a fourth term instead of being morons...

@LukePollard
Agree RT @benmiskell: If we want a Tory govt this type of rubbish certainly helps. The time for a change in leader passed along time ago

@LukePollard
Plotting MPs would be looked on a lot better if they delivered some leaflets instead of calling the media. #Doorstepsnotdarkcorners

@BevaniteEllie
Makes a change that Hoon and Hewitt aren't both former ministers who are bitter Blairites. Oh wait...

@Kexugdale
Message to hoon & hewitt - that ship has sailed! If your plan was to undermine the hardwork of 1000s of activists your succeeding

@PhilipHonour
geoff hoon may well just have cost Labout the election, thanks for that...idiot.

@estellehart
If Geoff Hoon thinks you're doing a bad job surely you're doing something right

@RobNewman
Spectacularly bad timing by Hoon after excellent PMQs. Unless someone in the Govt joins this "rebellion" it's doomed before it even begins

@BenFolley
First sight of Blairite coup letter via Tory site. Says it all.

@Kevin_McGuire
Polls narrowing, Cameron wobbling, Brown wins PMQs. Hoon-Hewitt raise leadership. Labour has a death wish

@GabyHinsliff
anti-Brown plot breaks http://bit.ly/66oIfO love the idea that balloting MPs on ditching GB cd be done with 'minimum disruption'...

@Luke_cb
Geoff Hoon got me a VIP entrance into a Derby County football match back in 2000. And I liked Hewitt. Shame really.

Read the full article Jan 06, 2010 at 01:14pm 34comments

Why this plot will fail

By Sunder Katwala / @nextleft

It still seems likely that the moment of maximum danger for Gordon Brown's leadership of the Labour Party into the General Election was the evening of Thursday June 4th 2009 when James Purnell resigned from the Cabinet, as the polls closed in the local and European elections, and other Cabinet members declined to follow him.

That evening, several of the most credible members of the political commentariat declared that Brown could not survive, as set out in my dissenting post that night.

And this point from last June as to why those judgements were premature, seems to me to remain the central point today:

Read the full article Jan 06, 2010 at 02:45pm 12comments

Kamikaze Hoon and Hewitt crash Labour's good start to the year

Thanks GeoffBy Gus Baker

Until today, 2010 had gone pretty well for Labour. David Cameron's marriage proposals have crashed and burned. Economic news is getting better. A hard hitting attack on the Tory budget black hole has been highly successful. Our campaign was on the up.

Read the full article Jan 06, 2010 at 02:21pm 15comments

Hoon and Hewitt call for secret ballot over Brown's leadership

Gordon BrownBy Alex Smith / @alexsmith1982

UPDATE: Full letter to the PLP is below:

Patricia Hewitt and Geoff Hoon are calling for a secret ballot within the Parliamentary Labour Party to determine the level of support for Gordon Brown's leadership amongst Labour MPs.

The letter says such a ballot would determine the leadership doubts "once and for all" - and either move forward with a new leader or allow Gordon Brown to lead Labour into the general election with a rallied party behind him.

The only way to resolve the issue of Brown's leadership, the letter says, is to allow every member of the PLP to "express their view".

For Brown's opponents, this is a much smarter way to try and determine the leadership issue than backstage plotting. Hoon and Hewitt are senoir figures who have not previously called or the PM's head - and this letter will force Brown and his supporters to act one way or the other. These new developments will bring the issue to a head.

But the point remains: if the asumption that the election will be held on May 6th is correct, and Brown is removed, a leadership bloodbath could ensue.

The full text of the letter is below:

Dear Colleague,

As we move towards a General Election it remains the case that the Parliamentary Labour Party is deeply divided over the question of the leadership. Many colleagues have expressed their frustration at the way in which this question is affecting our political performance. We have therefore come to the conclusion that the only way to resolve this issue would be to allow every member to express their view in a secret ballot.

This could be done quickly and with minimum disruption to the work of MPs and the Government. Whatever the outcome the whole of the party could then go forward, knowing that this matter had been sorted out once and for all.

Strong supporters of the Prime Minister should have no difficulty in backing this approach. There is a risk otherwise that the persistent background briefing and grumbling could continue up to and possibly through the election campaign, affecting our ability to concentrate all of our energies on getting our real message across.

Equally those who want change, should they lose such a vote, would be expected by the majority of the PLP to devote all of their efforts to winning the election. The implications of such a vote would be clear – everyone would be bound to support the result.

This is a clear opportunity to finally lay this matter to rest. The continued speculation and uncertainty is allowing our opponents to portray us as dispirited and disunited. It is damaging our ability to set out our strong case to the electorate. It is giving our political opponents an easy target.

In what will inevitably be a difficult and demanding election campaign, we must have a determined and united parliamentary party. It is our job to lead the fight against our political opponents. We can only do that if we resolve these distractions. We hope that you will support this proposal.

Yours fraternally,

Geoff Hoon and Patricia Hewitt

Read the full article Jan 06, 2010 at 12:42pm 35comments

Serious debate returns to PMQs

By Alex Smith / @alexsmith1982

I've just watched a much more grown up Prime Minister's Questions than we've become accostomed to of late. Although there were a few petty potshots fired between the PM and David Cameron, it was all relatively civil and the session dealt with some serious issues, including apprenticeships.

Nick Clegg performed well, in particular, and was afforded more respect by the government and opposition benches than he was before Christmas. Perhaps that's an indication of how much more seriously the main parties are taking the Liberal Democrats in the light of the possibility of a Hung Parliament after the election, or perhaps it's a sign that Clegg, who will feature on a level playing field with with Gordon Brown and David Cameron in April's TV debates, is growing in confidence.

LabourList is just getting back into the swing of things after the half-break over Christmas -- the PMQs LiveChat will return next week.

Read the full article Jan 06, 2010 at 12:36pm 4comments

Why, in spite of my Faith, I still believe in separation of Church and State

House of LordsBy Paul Burgin / @paul_burgin

Anyone who knows anything about Paul Blanchard and myself will know that when it comes to issues of Religion and Faith we are two very different people, apart from the fact that our beliefs in this area flow into the Labour Party. Primarily, Paul is involved with Labour Humanists and I am involved with the Christian Socialist Movement.

Read the full article Jan 06, 2010 at 11:56am 6comments

Blogs are great - but online political communication in the UK is still a disappointment

mYbOThe Labour movement column

By Anthony Painter / @anthonypainter

It is impossible to say what will be the defining issue or moment of the coming excruciatingly long election campaign. It could be the economy, public services, fiscal policy, optimism or pessimism for the future and a whole host of unforeseens besides.

Read the full article Jan 06, 2010 at 09:30am 14comments

Mandelson ready to fight for Brown - 8 in the morning, January 6th

Mandelson BrownBy Alex Smith / @alexsmith1982

* AMID REPORTS of new cabinet rifts, Peter Mandelson is returning to Gordon Brown's side today - and will give a speech calling for a diversification of the economy.

* THERE IS NO CHALLENGER to Gordon Brown's leadership, writes Jonathan Freedland.

* THE TIMES REPORTS that the new head of the Parliamentary Standards Authority, Ian Kennedy, has indicated that Sir Christopher Kelly's proposals on reforming MPs' expenses cannot work. Kennedy will give a speech today outlining alternative, lighter plans.

* A CROSS PARTY GROUP of MPs has urged for a 70million population cap to be in manifestos.

* JOHN RENTOUL has a plan to keep New Labour alive.

* TORY MARRIAGE POLICY will harm the young and the poor the most, finds Left Foot Forward.

* #KERRYOUT IS INEPTLY NEGATIVE, NASTY-PARTY STUFF, according to Sarah Ditum on the Guardian's Comment is Free.

* A BALLOT WILL BE HELD to determine who will attend Tony Blair's imminent appearance at the Chilcot Inquiry.

Read the full article Jan 06, 2010 at 08:18am 10comments

Marching on together: how Gordon Brown, just like Leeds, can still pull off a shock

Richard Robinson's Speech Bubble

Aged eight in 1970, I fell in love with both Leeds United and the Labour Party. We’ve been together through thick and thin ever since. As Leeds fans we recite our anthem at every match that despite our “ups and downs, we’re marching on together”.

Read the full article Jan 05, 2010 at 10:06pm 38comments

Labour Humanists ask: should the bishops be evicted from the House of Lords?

HumanistsBy Paul Blanchard

The UK is the only Western democracy that has clerics in its Parliament as of right. With reform of the House of Lords currently a hot topic, Labour Humanists are hosting an open debate on whether it is time to evict the "Lords Spiritual."

Read the full article Jan 05, 2010 at 08:20pm 15comments

Rumour mill can't detract from the question: what's changed since June?

Brown MandelsonBy Alex Smith / @alexsmith1982

The Evening Standard, Guido, the Spectator and Channel 4 News are all circulating the rumour that at least one cabinet minister - and perhaps two - may still be willing to resign if it means a new attempt to remove Gordon Brown from the Labour leadership would follow.

The story, originally trailed by Paul Waugh in the Standard, also picks up on Peter Mandelson's assertation that Labour cannot win the election on a core-vote strategy as a sign that new criticism of Brown's leadership is heading towards an enforced change at the top.

Waugh says:

Read the full article Jan 05, 2010 at 06:18pm 21comments

This is all about Dave and what Dave feels: we can't go on like this

All about David CameronBy Diana Smith / @mulberrybush

Yesterday, the hoardings went up all over the country: a large head shot of David Cameron enscribed “we can’t go on like this”.

The prospect of five whole months of electioneering is not an appealing one. Yesterday, I tuned in to hear David Cameron deliver his press release on the Health service. I did this because I really want to know. How is it that Dave sees the Health service, what is it that he actually intends to do and how does it differ from the actions that are already being taken by the Labour Government?

Dave’s promise of a less divisive kind of politics - in which he should also acknowledge the positive in the actions of his opponents - is just two days old. And it was a disappointment to me on two fronts: I did not get any of the detail I was looking for and we were back into Dave’s habitual attack mode.

Read the full article Jan 05, 2010 at 11:31am 127comments

Miliband v Miliband: the battle of brothers

Ed David MilibandBy Alex Smith / @alexsmith1982

Today's G2 has an interesting profile of the brothers Miliband - and their increasing "rivalry" over the prospect of attaining the Labour leadership in the future.

The feature, with a boxing-style billing on the section's front page, carries a number of interesting quotes from people close to both brothers.

Sir David King, the government's former chief scientist says:

Read the full article Jan 05, 2010 at 10:08am 66comments

PPC Profile: Paul Smith

Paul Smith Full name: Paul Smith

Age: 45

From: Bristol

PPC for: Bristol West

Website: paulsmith4bristolwest.org.uk

Blog: bristolwestpaul.wordpress.com/

Twitter: @bristolwestpaul

Selection Result: 51% on the first round

Member of the Labour Party since: 1982

CV:

Read the full article Jan 05, 2010 at 09:18am 20comments

First blood Labour as Tory marriage and health plans in confusion - 8 in the morning, January 5th

8amBy Alex Smith / @alexsmith1982

* LABOUR "DREW BLOOD" on the first day of the long campaign - pouncing on David Cameron's error on marriage tax plans and unveiling a 150-page document showing holes in the Osborne budget plans. The Guardian reports that, "in an attempt to demonstrate his fiscal responsibility, Cameron initially said of his tax incentives for married couple: 'It is something we want to do...[but] I am not today able to make that promise.' But within two hours, Cameron rushed out a statement saying: 'Recognising marriage in the tax system is something I feel very strongly about and something we will definitely do in the next parliament. We will set out exactly how in due course.'"

* AND THE TIMES reports that the Tories' "hasty" health pledges, announced yesterday, were "left in confusion" as their "draft manifesto on the NHS appeared to downgrade, change and omit several key promises."

* AT 6/1, bets on Labour to win the most seats at the election is a "popular choice".

* THE ELECTION IS LOOKING "INCREASINGLY TIGHT", says Blue State Digital's Matthew McGregor as the parties move online.

* THERE ARE OPTIONS for any potential post-election leadership debate, says John Harris.

* But in spite of the good start, Labour Party treasurers are INCREASINGLY CONCERNED at the party's financial position.

* ALASTAIR CAMPBELL WILL APPEAR at the Chilcot Inquiry next week.

* AN INDEPENDENT LEADER says the world must be careful in Yemen and develop a broa regional counter-terror strategy, as Yemeni forces claim to have killed Al-Qaida members.

Read the full article Jan 05, 2010 at 08:02am 12comments

Islam4UK should not be allowed to march through Wootton Bassett

Wootton Basset War coffinsBy Julian Ware-Lane / @WareLane

The freedom to protest, speak, have views, etc, has become a topic of debate, again. This time it is some Islamists who want to march through Wootton Bassett.

Islam4UK have a right to a voice, and a right to protest. I do not agree with their aims, but defend their right to voice them. However, they do not have the right to inflame passions, and this they would undoubtedly achieve should their desire to march through the town that witnesses the coming home of our dead service personnel.

Read the full article Jan 04, 2010 at 06:58pm 170comments

Where do we go from here?

LabourBy Alex Smith / @alexsmith1982

I've written a very brief few thoughts for the Progress website this afternoon, in which I answer the question: what should Gordon Brown do now?

My short response was to this loaded provocation was to say:

"Gordon Brown needs desperately to remind the country that Labour is the party of unrelenting reform; that change is no empty soundbite, rather that it is a hard-earned Labour principle; and that we have a rare opportunity in this financial and democratic climate to finish the work of remaking our public services so they may serve those who really need them."

Read the full article Jan 04, 2010 at 06:19pm 62comments

The top 10 progressive policies of the decade

LFFBy Alex Smith / @alexsmith1982

This afternoon, Left Foot Forward have published their Top 10 Progressive Policies of the Noughties.

I would have liked, of course, to see universal free school meals added to the list - but the noted achievements are nonetheless substantial:

1. Reducing Child Poverty
2. Investment (in public services and buildings)
3. Recapitalisation of the banks
4. UK leadership on international development
5. Sure Start
6. EU renewables
7. The Freedom of Information Act (which - incidentally - is five years old today)
8. Quality of Life (not a government policy this one, but a nod to the work of the Quality of Life Policy Group, which sought to measure development through metrics other than GDP)
9. Civil Partnerships
10. Free access to museums

There are also a selection of the 5 regressive policies of the decade:

1. Iraq
2. Lack of regulation
3. 10p tax band abolition
4. Increasing detention without charge
5. Inheritance Tax

Read the full Left Foot Forward post here.

Read the full article Jan 04, 2010 at 04:26pm 93comments

Labour must reopen the narrative of the political giants

Blair BrownBy Joshua Genner

“The Noughties belong lock, stock and broken barrel to Tony Blair and Gordon Brown. For better or for worse, these were the political giants who dominated the first decade of this millennium.”

So said The Sun on Friday - and I find myself asking 'what will be remembered of these giants?'

Read the full article Jan 04, 2010 at 03:33pm 19comments

Brown demonstrates how to drive away the wavering voter

Brown PMQsBy Giles Wilkes

To abandon a cherished political saying, just because Fraser Nelson believes it doesn’t mean it’s nonsense. But if David Cameron can be accused by the Speccie of conning the voters about the pain to come, then Gordon Brown’s offence is much worse: he at least has the numbers at hand, some of the responsibilty, and a huge team to help him work his way through.

Read the full article Jan 04, 2010 at 02:27pm 68comments

Join our Day of Action to defeat the BNP - this Saturday

Beat BNPBy Margaret Hodge MP

I wanted to remind you about our Beat the BNP Day of Action this Saturday, 9th January.

We will be meeting at Becontree tube station (on the District Line) at 10am and then we will be going out door knocking and delivering leaflets from 10-12pm and, after a buffet lunch, again at 1-3pm.

For years the BNP have dreamed of a seat at Westminster, and this time they think they have a chance. But I am determined that 2010 will be the year that dream is put to an end.

Here in Barking we need your support and solidarity to do this. So it would be fantastic if you could join us on Saturday, and please do bring along any friends or family members who are interested as well.

If you have any questions, you can call our campaign hotline on 07576 323 109 or send an email to liz.bradshaw.07@googlemail.com.

All good wishes and Happy New Year.

Read the full article Jan 04, 2010 at 12:46pm 110comments